I’m about to reveal my top three beaches. I must confess, I’m not sure I really want to share them. I’d much rather keep them all to myself…
I grew up in Ireland, where even in the heat of summer, the sea is still a little chilly. And, in winter, it’s downright cold. I’m much happier with warm water, where you don’t need a wetsuit to go for a swim.
And, I prefer beaches where you don’t get hassled. I don’t want someone trying to sell me cheap souvenirs or a tacky t-shirt every few minutes. I’d much rather read and think and relax uninterrupted.
So, here’s my top three. And, my take on whether they’d make good locations for a vacation home.
Doctor’s Cave Beach, Montego Bay, Jamaica
Doctor’s Cave Beach is in Montego Bay, a bustling town and busy cruise ship port in Jamaica. But this beach is a little oasis. A Dr. McCatty donated his beach property to start a bathing club in 1906. Most of the first members were his friends and fellow medics, hence the name. The beach became famous in the 1920s when Sir Herbert Barker declared that he was restored to good health after bathing there—and concluded that the waters had “curative powers.”
I’m not convinced by his theory. But you definitely feel amazingly recharged after a day relaxing on this beach.
Perfect sand, perfect water…Doctor’s Cave Beach is an Instagram dream.
Visitors pay $6 for access. There are changing rooms and showers on site. You can rent chairs, umbrellas, and Li-los. And the club’s restaurant and bar make it easy to get snacks, lunch, or fancy cocktails.
While I’d love to go back to this beach, I wouldn’t invest in a second home in this place. The real estate I scouted didn’t offer much in terms of capital appreciation or strong rental yields. With one-bedroom condos running around $250,000 and two-bedrooms from $500,000 up, I feel you’re better off putting your money in other Caribbean beach destinations such as my next two picks…
Playa Rincon, Samana, Dominican Republic
This beach was a lucky find some years back. A driver had picked me up very early in the morning and taken me from one property to another around the Samana peninsula. He was (like most Dominicans I’ve met) very friendly and chatty. He was also on a mission to prove that his home island could stand up there with the best in the world on all fronts (food, music, sport, and beaches).
On the way back to my base in the town of Las Terrenas, he suggested a detour. To show me the best beach in the world. We set off down a rutted, bumpy track. “It will be worth it,” the driver grinned, “just you wait.” He was right.
Playa Rincon is a gorgeous curve of soft, fine sand. The west side of the bay has a couple of restaurants and beach loungers. The setting is wild, natural, and unspoiled, with palm trees covering the green hills around the bay. The biggest surprise was the fact that this incredible beach was empty: we had it all to ourselves.
Escape from it all at Playa Rincon, a hidden getaway in the Dominican Republic.
Close to Playa Rincon, the little beach town of Las Terrenas is a fantastic second home location. It’s low rise and low key, with good restaurants and cafés and miles of pretty beaches to explore. An established vacation spot for Europeans, it’s now attracting more North Americans. Some spend the winter months in Las Terrenas. Shorts and flip-flops has way more appeal than shoveling snow and cranking up the heating…
You can buy an in-town condo in Las Terrenas for as little as $150,000. And your second home can earn good rental income. There’s a shortage of accommodation at peak times (from November through to Easter) and owners can make double-digit rental returns.
X’Cacel Beach, Riviera Maya, Mexico.
This is another beach that I discovered on a scouting trip through a local contact. It’s pristine and should stay that way thanks to some very strict rules.
The beach is an important turtle nesting site. You pass through a checkpoint on the way in where you are asked to make a small donation to fund beach cleaning and conservation. Then you park your car and stroll up to this unspoiled beach.
This turtle nesting beach boasts pristine sand and a little freshwater cenote.
There are no hotels on this beach. Camping is banned, as are pets and bonfires. You just bring your cooler with some drinks and snacks and enjoy…
Just beside the beach there’s a natural freshwater sinkhole (a cenote). The water in the cenote is cool and refreshing, a lovely contrast to the warm Caribbean Sea.
This quiet beach is tucked away between the towns of Playa del Carmen and Tulum. This stretch of coast is home to dozens of spectacular beaches, so keep your camera at the ready. And it’s a coast that’s an excellent location for a second home.
It’s probably the easiest Caribbean destination to get to—the international airport has flight connections across North and South America and Europe. Second homes (especially off-beach condos) are still very affordable with pricing from as low as $200,000 for a two-bedroom condo. And, this is a place where you can make good rental income from a second home…generating income of $35,000 a year in Tulum and as much as $55,000 a year in Playa from a well-located two-bedroom condo.
Get Your Free Roving Real Estate Investor Report Now
Sign up for the FREE Roving Real Estate Investor e-letter and get a valuable report (free for a limited time) on The 5 Best Places in the World to Own a Home From $150,000.